inabitofapickle
inabitofapickle
  • Home
  • Pickle Pack
  • Pickle Universe
  • Pickle Store
  • Pickle Articles
  • Pickle Reviews
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Pickle Pack
    • Pickle Universe
    • Pickle Store
    • Pickle Articles
    • Pickle Reviews
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Pickle Pack
  • Pickle Universe
  • Pickle Store
  • Pickle Articles
  • Pickle Reviews
  • Contact
Supermarket shelves stocked with jars and packets of pickles and olives.

The 5 Best Pickles You Can Buy at Australian Supermarkets

You don't need to hunt down an obscure German delicatessen or a bearded, tattooed pickle maker operating out the back of a gin distillery to find a great pickle. Although, to be fair, you're likely to find some pretty good pickles that way too. We've reviewed plenty of pickles that you can find at Australian supermarkets. Some have been excellent. Some have been average. And some have made us wonder what the poor cucumber did to deserve such treatment.


It's important to remember that there isn't really one “best” pickle. A crunchy dill pickle eaten straight from the jar in the fridge is a very different beast from a sweet and tangy burger pickle. 


The trick is finding the right pickle for the job - so we've come up with the best pickle in five different categories across our Pickle Universe.



BEST CLASSIC DILL SUPERMARKET PICKLE: McClure's Whole Garlic & Dill Pickles

Rating: 9.3/10


Simple ingredients. Garlic. Dill. Vinegar. Salt. Cucumber. Sometimes you really don't need to mess with things. McClure's Whole Garlic & Dill remains one of the highest-rated pickles we've reviewed. The smaller whole cucumbers are seriously crunchy, the garlic and dill flavour is clean and uncomplicated, and there's none of the artificial colouring and unnecessary additions that let down plenty of cheaper pickles congregating on the bottom shelf at the supermarket.


These are particularly good straight from the jar, but they're equally at home alongside a deli sandwich or cheese board.


In the Pickle Universe: Vinegar Pickled • Dill/Kosher Dill • Very low sweetness • Medium sourness • Very high crunch. 


Better still, you don't need to go hunting for them. Coles currently lists the 500g jar at $5.80, and they're also available at Woolworths. 


Best for: Straight-from-the-jar snacking, deli sandwiches, garlic lovers.

Read our full McClure's Whole Garlic & Dill review



BEST VALUE SUPERMARKET PICKLE: Always Fresh Polskie Ogorki

Rating: 9.0/10
 

This might be the least glamorous recommendation on the list, but it's the jar we're most likely to throw into the trolley when perusing the pickle aisle.


Despite the Polskie Ogorki name, a traditional Polish pickle this ain't. They're vinegar-pickled and made in India. Forget the slightly confusing geography, though, because what's inside the jar is excellent.


They're small, crisp, visually appealing and have a lovely acidic kick, with dill, mustard seed, onion and red capsicum adding some extra interest. Most importantly, the crunch is outstanding.


At the time of our original review, we called them one of the best-value options on the market, and that still looks fair. 


In the Pickle Universe: Vinegar Pickled • Gherkin/Dill • Low sweetness • Medium-high sourness • Very high crunch. 


They're currently stocked by both Coles and Woolworths, with the normal price around $4.60 for 680g. 


Best for: Snacking, sandwiches, salads and anyone who wants a very good everyday pickle without paying much for it.

Read our full Always Fresh Polskie Ogorki review



BEST TRADITIONAL SUPERMARKET GHERKIN: Ceres Organics Gherkins

Rating: 9.0/10


If someone asked us to show them what a great gherkin should look and taste like, these would the demonstration model.


Ceres Organics gets the gherkin fundamentals right: relatively small cucumbers, proper crunch, plenty of flavour and a brine containing dill, mustard seed and other herbs and spices. The organic certification is nice, but it isn't why these make the list. They're here because they're seriously good pickles.


There is enough happening in the brine to make them interesting without losing sight of the cucumber itself. They're also hugely versatile, working in sandwiches, potato salad, with cheese or simply liberated directly from the fridge.


In the Pickle Universe: Vinegar Pickled • Gherkin • Low-medium sweetness • Medium sourness • Very high crunch. 


Ceres Organics Gherkins are currently available at Woolworths, so these aren't some left-field recommendation either that you can only by at a bohemian cafe in Fremantle. 


Best for: Sandwiches, salads, cheese, organic shoppers and general-purpose gherkin duties.

Read our full Ceres Organics Gherkins review



BEST MODERN-FLAVOURED SUPERMARKET PICKLE: McClure's Sweet & Spicy Pickles

Rating: 8.8/10


If the Whole Garlic & Dill is McClure's keeping things beautifully simple, this is McClure's deciding to have some fun.


These crinkle-cut slices somehow manage to be sweet, spicy, dilly and tangy at the same time. Apple cider vinegar softens the acidity, onion and garlic provide complexity, and chilli gives them warmth without completely taking over.


On paper, it sounds as though there might be too much going on. In the jar, it works.


In the Pickle Universe: Vinegar Pickled • Modern Flavours • Medium-high sweetness • Medium sourness • Medium-high crunch. 


McClure's Sweet & Spicy pickles are currently available at both Coles and Woolworths.


Best for: Burgers, sandwiches, cheese and crackers and people bored with standard dill pickles.

Read our full McClure's Sweet & Spicy review



BEST AUSTRALIAN SUPERMARKET PICKLE (AND BURGER PICK): Westmont Dill Sour

Rating: 8.5/10


We couldn't have a list of the best supermarket pickles in Australia without an Australian pickle.


Westmont's Dill Sour is straightforward, locally made and particularly good value. The sliced cucumbers aren't going to challenge a tiny whole gherkin for the crunch championship, but that's missing the point. Put these into a burger or sandwich and they make complete sense.


They're slightly sweeter than the “Dill Sour” name might suggest, but the combination of dill, peppercorns, salt and that touch of sweetness make them extremely easy to eat.


In our original review we described them as “much better than most of the cheap imports beside them on the shelf.” We stand by it. Buy Australian!


In the Pickle Universe: Vinegar Pickled • Dill/Kosher Dill • Medium sweetness • Medium sourness • Medium crunch. 


Westmont Dill Sour pickles are currently available at Woolworths. Bonus points awarded for containing all Australian ingredients. 


Best for: Burgers, sandwiches, Aussie pickle supporters and everyday lunches.

Read our full Westmont Dill Sour review


So, what are the best supermarket pickles in Australia? Well, that depends on what you're looking for. If you're still confused, head over to our Pickle Universe and explore the different methods and styles, along with an interactive chart with every pickle we've reviewed.


And remember: there's always room in the fridge for another jar.






Get yourself in a bit of pickle!


Like this article as much as you like a good value, crunchy supermarket pickle?


Join The Pickle Post for reviews, recommendations, pickle news, new discoveries and everything worth knowing from the wonderful world of pickles.

Subscribe to The Pickle Post

Subscribe to the pickle post

Get the latest pickle reviews, articles, discoveries and special offers delivered straight to your inbox. (No spam. Just pickles)


Copyright © 2026 inabitofapickle - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Contact

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept